"those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
I am sure that slavery will never come back to the United States, but Santayana's point is that we cannot just forget about things that happened long ago. It wouldn't make sense to disregard a part of history - merely because it is appalling.
Therefore, it wouldn't make sense to remove the 'n' - word, or 'injun', from Mark Twain's work, Huckleberry Finn. First of all, it would distort the past, to hide our feelings from what was and what cannot be changed. Second of all, it would be taking away an important part of the work, which creates a feeling of disgust, yet approval when Huck distances himself from society, and loses the racism which was taught to him.
In conclusion, as much as I am opposed to the 'n'-word, I would have to say that it should be left in Huckleberry Finn. Yes, racism is completely alien, and wrong. But Mark Twain put it in for a reason, "Twain himself was a passionate critic of American racism" (Benedicte Page). He wrote down history in a way which would keep it from being forgotten, and who are we to change a great writer's story?
No comments:
Post a Comment